Promotion Dossier Tips for Clinical and Teaching-Track Faculty

Key takeaways
Clinical, teaching-track and professional-track faculty are usually judged on different criteria than tenure-track research faculty. Find the guidelines for your specific track and rank.
Make teaching, clinical or professional practice, and service the core of your case, with evidence of impact for each.
Count scholarship in the forms your track values, such as teaching research, case reports, or educational materials.
Open your personal statement by explaining your appointment because reviewers may not know your role.
Clinical, teaching-track and professional-track faculty are evaluated on different criteria than tenure-track research faculty, and their dossiers should reflect that. The strongest dossiers present teaching, clinical or professional practice, and service as the core of the case, with clear evidence of excellence and impact in each.
These roles are now common in higher education. According to the AAUP, about 68 percent of US faculty held contingent appointments in fall 2023, meaning they were not tenured or on the tenure track. In US medical schools, the AAUP reports that only about 26 percent of faculty held full-time tenured or tenure-track appointments in fall 2023, down from about 39 percent in 2002. Yet most dossier advice is written for tenure-track research faculty.
1. Start with your own criteria, not the tenure-track criteria
Many institutions have separate promotion guidelines for clinical, teaching, lecturer, or professor of practice tracks. Find the guidelines for your specific track, title, and rank. Read your appointment letter too, because it may set out your expected balance of teaching, practice, service, and scholarship.
If your institution has no separate guidelines, ask your chair how the general criteria are applied to your role.
2. Make teaching the centerpiece
For many teaching-track faculty, teaching excellence is the main criterion. Go beyond student evaluations. The AAUP's Statement on Teaching Evaluation supports drawing on peer review and evidence of student learning, not student ratings alone. Strong evidence includes:
Peer observations and teaching center consultations
Course and curriculum development, including new courses, programs, or online offerings
Evidence of student learning and student outcomes
Teaching innovations and how you assessed them
Teaching awards and teaching-related professional development
See our guide on how to write a tenure teaching statement for a structure you can adapt.
3. Document clinical or professional practice
For clinical faculty, practice is often a major part of the case. Describe:
Your clinical or practice role, volume, and settings
Quality improvement projects and their outcomes
Supervision of students, residents, or trainees in practice settings
Development of protocols, programs, or services
Recognition from peers, such as referrals, awards, or leadership roles
Where possible, include outcomes, such as improved patient care, new services or trainees supervised.
4. Show scholarship in the forms your track values
Many clinical and teaching tracks still expect some scholarship, but not always traditional research. Depending on your guidelines, this may include:
The scholarship of teaching and learning (SoTL)
Case reports, clinical reviews, or practice guidelines
Educational materials, textbooks, or open educational resources
Presentations at teaching or professional conferences
Contributions to accreditation or curriculum standards
Frame this work clearly as scholarship and explain its reach. Many of the principles in our guide to writing a tenure research statement, such as organizing work into themes and showing impact, apply here too.
5. Present service and leadership as impact
Teaching-track and clinical faculty often carry heavy service loads, such as program direction, advising, accreditation, and committee work. Show what changed because of your work. Our guide on how to write a tenure service statement explains how.
6. Tell one clear story
Reviewers on promotion committees may include tenure-track faculty unfamiliar with your role. Open your personal statement by explaining your appointment and how your work is weighted. Then show how your teaching, practice, scholarship, and service fit together.
Common mistakes to avoid
Imitating a research-track dossier. It can make your strongest work look secondary.
Assuming reviewers understand your role. Explain your appointment and workload in plain terms.
Underreporting teaching and practice. These are often your main criteria, so give them the most detail and evidence.
Ignoring promotion timelines. Some tracks allow promotion at flexible points. Confirm when you are eligible and plan backward. Our tenure dossier timeline can help.
What goes in your promotion dossier?
Most of the components overlap with a tenure dossier, but the weighting differs. Use our tenure portfolio checklist as a starting point, then adjust it to your track's guidelines.
Preparing for promotion on a clinical or teaching track? Academic Consults works with faculty in all appointment types to build clear, well-evidenced promotion dossiers. Learn about Tenure Portfolio Coaching or schedule a consultation.
Frequently asked questions
Can clinical faculty get tenure? It depends on the institution. Some offer tenure on clinical tracks, but many clinical and teaching-track appointments are not tenure-eligible. They offer promotion through ranks instead.
What goes in a promotion dossier for teaching-track faculty? Usually a CV, a teaching statement, a service statement, evidence of teaching effectiveness, and any scholarship your track requires. Check your track's guidelines.
Do teaching-track faculty need to publish? Some tracks require no publications. Others expect some scholarship, such as teaching and learning research or educational materials. Your guidelines and appointment letter will say.
Who reviews promotion dossiers for clinical faculty? Often a department committee, a college committee, and senior administrators. Sometimes external reviewers are also asked to evaluate your work.
What is the difference between a teaching-track and a clinical-track appointment? Teaching-track roles center on instruction and curriculum. Clinical-track roles usually combine teaching with clinical or professional practice, such as patient care or supervising trainees in practice settings. Titles and expectations vary by institution.
Related reading
Caroline Eisner is an academic writing coach and certified professional co-active coach who works with tenure-track faculty on publications and research productivity. She has previously worked at Georgetown University and the Sweetland Center for Writers at the University of Michigan.




Comments