top of page
Search

What to Include in a Tenure Portfolio: A Checklist

Nov 3
4 min read
Organized tenure portfolio binders and documents on a desk

Key takeaways


  • A tenure portfolio, also called a dossier, file, or packet, typically includes your CV, research, teaching, and service statements, and supporting evidence for each.

  • External review letters and chair or dean letters are usually added by your department, not by you.

  • Your institution's guidelines always override any general checklist.


A tenure portfolio, also called a tenure dossier, file or packet, is the collection of documents reviewers use to decide whether you meet your institution's standards for tenure. Most portfolios include your CV, personal statements on research, teaching and service, and supporting evidence for each area. External review letters are usually added by your department.


Requirements vary widely by institution, so your own guidelines always come first. Use this checklist as a starting point and adapt it to what your department asks for.


Core documents

  • Academic CV in your institution's required format

  • Research or scholarship statement describing your agenda, accomplishments, impact, and future plans. See how to write a tenure research statement.

  • Teaching statement describing your teaching philosophy, methods, and growth as an educator

  • Service statement describing your contributions to your department, institution, profession, and community

  • Personal or candidate statement if your institution asks for one overall narrative instead of separate statements

  • Your offer letter or appointment letter if it sets out specific expectations for tenure


Evidence of research and scholarship

  • Copies of your publications, or a list with links, as your institution requires

  • Grant awards, applications, and funding records

  • Conference presentations and invited talks

  • Evidence of impact, such as citations, reviews of your work, awards, or media coverage. If your institution has signed the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment (DORA), qualitative evidence of influence carries extra weight.

  • Creative work, exhibitions, or performances, for arts and humanities faculty

  • Work in progress, such as manuscripts under review or submitted grants


Evidence of teaching effectiveness

  • Student course evaluations, often with a summary table across semesters

  • Peer teaching observations

  • Sample syllabi, assignments, and course materials

  • Examples of new courses or major course revisions you developed

  • Student mentoring and advising, including theses and research supervision

  • Teaching awards or professional development in teaching


Don't rely on student evaluations alone. In an AAUP faculty survey, 50 percent of respondents said student evaluations are not an effective way to determine good teaching, while 47 percent said they are. Peer observations, course materials, and evidence of student learning give reviewers a fuller picture. (Source: AAUP)


Evidence of service

  • Department, college, and university committee work, with your role on each

  • Service to your profession, such as reviewing journals, editing, or leading in associations

  • Community engagement connected to your academic work

  • Leadership roles and any significant outcomes of your service


Materials often added by your department

  • External review letters from scholars in your field

  • Department and committee evaluations

  • Chair's or dean's letter


You usually do not prepare these yourself, but you may be asked to suggest external reviewers or provide a list of people who should not review your file. Our tenure dossier timeline explains when to start building those relationships.


Tips for organizing your tenure portfolio

  • Follow your institution's order exactly. Reviewers read many files and expect a familiar structure.

  • Label everything clearly. Use consistent file names, section headings, and page numbers.

  • Choose your strongest evidence. More is not always better. Include what best supports your case.

  • Connect the evidence to your statements. Your statements should point to the evidence, and the evidence should back up what your statements claim.

  • Have someone review the complete file. A fresh reader will catch gaps, repetition, and unclear sections you may miss.


Want a second set of eyes on your portfolio? Academic Consults helps faculty organize their tenure materials, strengthen their statements, and present a clear, cohesive case. Learn about Tenure Portfolio Coaching or schedule a consultation.


Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a tenure portfolio and a tenure dossier? They usually mean the same thing. Institutions use different names, including portfolio, dossier, file, packet, and case.


What is the most important part of a tenure portfolio? Your statements and CV are usually read most closely because they frame how reviewers understand everything else in the file.


How long is a typical tenure portfolio? It varies widely. Some are a few dozen pages, and others run to several hundred once supporting evidence is included. Follow any page limits your institution sets.


Do I include every teaching evaluation I have received? Often yes, but check your guidelines. Many institutions require all evaluations since your appointment, sometimes with a summary.


When should I start gathering materials for my tenure portfolio? In your first year on the tenure track. See our year-by-year tenure dossier timeline.


Related reading


Caroline Eisner is an academic writing coach and certified professional co-active coach who works with tenure-track faculty on publications and research productivity. She has previously worked at Georgetown University and the Sweetland Center for Writers at the University of Michigan.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page